Saturday, November 6, 2010

Ballot Position Cited as One Factor in Efforts to Win Ballot Status

Since the election, I have gotten a lot of voter and reader comments about how difficult is was to find the candidates who drew the short straw and ended up at the bottom of the ballot.
Among them were gubernatorial candidates Charles Barron and Kristin Davis who were in a separate column because the Governor column was filled with cross endorsements and other candidates. People tell me it was confusing, so it may be more than coincidence the isolated candidates finished last and next to last with about half as many votes as the other candidates.
Another shrewd move that helped a candidate was Jimmy McMillans decision to have no running mate. That meant a single name in the box which stood out more and was more readable. (see comment below, Jimmy may have been more lucky than shrewd)
Of course McMillan's Rent too High schtick at the debate caught the media fancy and made him the publicity darling of the MSM. He became the novelty candidate.
None of the minor candidates had extensive organizations. The Greens and Libertarians do have a framework of organization which helped. Davis had the most sophisticated strategy effort with Roger's help. McMillan had nothing other than the buzz he got by wearing black gloves and barking "the Rents too DAMN High."
Now, I am not suggesting the whole race hinged on ballot position, but there is no doubt it is a factor, and that is why all these groups wanted to win ballot status for the next four years.
Message and candidate matter to be sure, but in the absence of a Golisano-size checkbook to buy your way to 50,000, the little things like position are a big deal.
Also, with fewer than 200,000 people willing to vote for a minor candidate, the five candidate field was crowded.
In the end, the Greens won ballot status. They also had the best ballot position on Tuesday.

8 comments:

TDS said...

He's lucky he didn't get sued-- a guy named Steven Cohn got thrown off the ballot because he didn't have a LG candidate after the Paladino campaign complained. You're legally required to have an LG candidate. Jimmy got lucky that a p-o'ed Randy Credico didn't go after him in revenge (Jimmy apparently screwed him out of a chance at a Democrat primary against Schumer).

And the other thing about those ballots-- on the downballot selections, they shortchanged several candidates who had multiple ballot lines and just listed two parties on one ballot line. Credico got two ballot lines and only had one on the ballot, with two names. Joe DioGuardi had his Conservative and Taxpayers lines on the same line. That defeats the whole point of fusion, doesn't it?

Jeff Graham said...

Didn't notice that till you pointed it out....

Anonymous said...

At least the Senator "Goat Boy" got elected and its something all Republicans should be proud of. Greg Ball has some serious issues in his past to deal with.
http://exiledonline.com/did-republican-greg-ball-stage-his-own-dead-goat-threat/
http://thetruthaboutgregball.com/Military_Experience.html
http://www.nydailynews.com/ny_local/2010/07/03/2010-07-03_womens_group_demands_probe_of_pol_in_grope.html
http://www.nydailynews.com/news/2008/08/26/2008-08-26_upstate_assemblyman_greg_ball_accused_of.html
The voters spoke and said they want Goat Boy!!!!!!!!!beeeeeeeeeeeehhhhhhhhhhhhhh. lol

Anonymous said...

Then Greens also had the best message.

Dan Francis said...

This ballot system we now have sucks.

The machine reads it fine - that part is okay, but that assumes you marked the ballot the way you want in the first place.

If you make a mistake, the machine barfs out your ballot and you march back the table, wait in line, and do the process again... even as some might peer over your shoulder to see your rejected ballot and how you voted.

We need something like the old "level" "x" system: pull the level, it blocks other lines, and you push the red button to vote.

Simple, easy and something we all understand... that or develp and implement a push button device that pulls up one candidate at a time while you stand and vote for hours ... whatever, the sytem now in place has to go.

Anonymous said...

And Dan, don't we wonder what becomes of that discarded ballot? Mine wouldn't record because they ripped it out of a book or something and it had an irregular edge. There were two of them at that polling site.

Anonymous said...

I left the AG choice blank and it did not spit it back out.
I don't trust the machines.
No one ever asked me for ID either.

Anonymous said...

Since the days of illegals being encouraged to vote, in fact longer than that, they haven't asked for ID. That would interfere with a Guatamalan's right to vote Donkey.